UK Asbestos Deaths a Growing Concern
November 14th, 2008Britain has the same long history of mining and industrialization that the United States does. The British Health and Safety Executive (HSE) is an office similar to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration in the United States. Here’s what the HSE has to say about asbestos in the UK workplace today:
“Asbestos: The greatest single cause of work-related deaths in the UK.”
With a population of sixty million, the UK has 4,000 deaths annually that are attributed to mesothelioma. The United States has about 3,000 with a population five times that of the UK. Moreover, the rate of mesothelioma cancer deaths is still climbing in the UK, whereas it has leveled out in the United States and is actually showing some signs of slowing down.
As part of a national campaign to raise awareness of the workplace dangers of asbestos, the HSE has been publicizing some of the stark realities of the problem. A recent BBC story detailed the death rate in a portion of Scotland that includes Edinburgh, Fife and the Lothians. A study showed that 528 residents of the area died due to mesothelioma during the last two decades of the twentieth century: 1981-2000.
Of the four thousand Britons dying each year from mesothelioma, about a quarter are former tradesmen – but the HSE notes that “it fears today’s plumbers, electricians and joiners underestimate the ongoing risk.” The UK a history of architecture that predates building in the United States by several hundred years. The older buildings in the UK are loaded with asbestos insulation, both commercial structures and residential.
Despite the omnipresent threat of old, crumbling asbestos in buildings that are being remodeled, the HSE estimates that one of ten tradesmen pay any attention to the safety requirements that involve removing or working around old asbestos. As a result, the accelerating tragedy of mesothelioma deaths continues unabated. From another BBC story; “Exposure to the material remains the biggest single cause of work-related deaths, likely to peak at around 5,000 per year in the next five years, the HSE says.”
The Real Problem Underestimated
HSE disease reduction program director Steve Coldrick said: “We have a legacy of 500,000 commercial or industrial buildings in this country which still contain asbestos and it is the tradesmen who are at risk from it now…Unless we make them really understand the problems it can cause, in 20 or 50 years time we will have even more people dying.”
Organized labor sees the problem differently. Alan Ritchie, general secretary of the builders’ union in the UK said that members who raised concerns about working with asbestos were rapidly losing confidence in the HSE. “When investigating these complaints, rather than talk to the workers whose health is being put at risk, they instead simply speak to the management, who invariably give the organization a clean bill of health.”
There is also skepticism among the members of the academic community: Professor Rory O’Neill, of Stirling University’s Occupational and Environmental Health Research Group, said the HSE’s figures were a “woeful” underestimate of the death rate. “A more realistic figure would be 5,000 – 6,000″ he said.



